What can we learn from comparing pupils in England to their peers in other countries?

20 March 2025

The TIMSS international research project aims to compare attainment in pupils across a wide range of countries has interesting and wide-reaching implications for science teachers. For those less inclined to read the 500+ pages of the report, I have summarised the key findings for secondary science and suggested what teachers and leaders should consider through their curriculum implementation.

TIMSS is a research project that happens every 4 years across 66 countries, most recently in 2023. Over 8000 pupils in England from Year 5 and Year 9 are tested on science and mathematics questions that can be benchmarked to track changes in attainment over time. Contextual data is also gathered to understand the factors which affect performance, including the attitudes of pupils to science and maths. TIMSS isn’t just a measure of pupils’ achievement in a test; it also helps us understand pupils’ context and how that might affect their performance – vital if you aim to move the needle on pupil progress.

With such a large dataset, a broad set of factors, it is important to take the conclusions with a pinch of salt. Science teachers will be familiar with the “correlation does not mean causation” adage; it might not be appropriate to make wholesale changes to practice based on this report alone. Instead, this can form part of a larger conversation around strategies to support students; this is particularly important when looking at the social justice issues that emerge from the data.

What are the trends over time?

  • More Year 9 pupils reported that their teacher provided high instructional quality than in 2019.
  • Results are up in Year 9, but there is still a way to go to return to their pre-2019 levels.
  • In Year 9, boys performed significantly above girls for the first time since 2003. This gap also occurred in maths (in maths the gap is also visible for Year 5 pupils).
  • The gap between the highest and lowest performing students has increased; this is because England’s highest performing students are doing better but there is not an equivalent improvement for the lowest performing students.
  • There has been a decrease in pupils reporting that they feel very or somewhat confident in science since 2019. However, more pupils in report enjoying science.

Implications for teachers and leaders

  • Examine your departmental data to see if there is evidence of an emerging difference in performance between boys and girls.
  • Consider how your staff are using teaching techniques to increase pupil success and build confidence over time.

How does England compare to other countries?

  • In both years 5 and 9, pupils in England perform significantly above the average but below a group of 4 or 5 high-performing countries (all from Asia).
  • England performs well compared to comparator groups of European and English-speaking countries.
  • One concerning comparison is the range of results shown for England’s pupils; the gap between the highest and lowest performing Year 9 pupils is greater for England than any other country (joint with Singapore).
  • No other country has such a wide gap in performance between Year 9 boys and girls. In most of the highest performing counties, there are no significant differences between boys and girls.
  • In Year 9, there are some countries which perform significantly better than England. For instance, 47% of pupils reached the “Advanced” benchmark, compared to only 17% for England.
  • With the exception of the Republic of Korea amongst the highest-performing schools and Canada amongst English-speaking countries, pupils reported the highest levels of instructional quality in Year 5. Sadly, this does not hold for Year 9; instructional quality in science is below the international average (according to pupil reporting).
  • Teachers in England are much more likely to report having too many administrative tasks compared to the international average.

Implications for teachers and leaders

  • Teacher quality matters; how do your departmental improvement plans support teacher development to ensure all students are getting the best deal?
  • Ensure you are not just looking at averages when analysing school data; the range of results is also important. With that in mind, include subgroups during data collection and compare their progress and attainment.
  • Look at the administrative tasks teachers are asked to complete and consider how this can be streamlined.

What subjects/topics/domains does England do better/worse in?

  • In Year 9, pupils are not significantly better or worse at any of the subjects (biology, chemistry, physics). Previously (in 2015), pupils performed significantly better in biology and worse in chemistry, but these gaps disappeared in 2019.
  • In 2023, pupils in Year 9 were weaker at applying compared to reasoning or knowing. This was not the same as in previous years; performance in applying fluctuates across the most recent TIMSS cycles. In high-performing countries, these differences do not exist.

Implications for teachers and leaders

  • Use your exam board’s portal to examine previous cohort’s performance across the different Assessment Objectives. If you use a platform like SmartGrade that allows breakdown by AO, analyse the data to see if current groups have differences in their performance across AOs. Use this information to tailor your exam question practice and adapt lessons to build skills across all three objectives.

What differences are there in how distinct groups of pupils performed?

  • As already mentioned, boys outperformed girls in Year 9 science (for the first time).
  • Boys are more likely to report high instructional quality than girls in Year 9. Also, girls are much more likely to report being less confident in science (60% vs. 44%) in Year 9.
  • Pupils eligible for free school meals perform worse than those who are not eligible.
  • Pupils with EAL do significantly worse than those for whom English is a first language.
  • There is a strong correlation between performance and how many books are in a student’s home.
  • There is an, unsurprising, correlation between a pupils’ attendance and their scores in both year groups.

Implications for teachers and leaders

  • Consider whether girls in your school might be experiencing a less positive classroom experience than boys. A pupil voice exercise might reveal opportunities to build an equitable learning environment for all.
  • Build an understanding of how the performance of groups of students in your school differs from the average. How does your curriculum actively support the provision for these students? This guide from the EEF provides a good starting point for these discussions.

How do pupils’ attitude to science affect performance?

  • Pupils who feel confident in science perform better than those who do not; this effect is higher in Year 9 than in Year 5.
  • There are correlations between how much both pupils enjoy science and also how much they value science and how they perform.
  • Boys are more confident in science and more likely to report liking the subject. This could explain the gap in attainment between genders.
  • The extent to which pupils enjoy learning science affects the performance of boys and girls differently; boys who like learning science outperform girls but boys who do not perform worse (leading to a larger range in performance for boys).

Implications for teachers and leaders

  • Use pupil voice to identify where pupils are feeling less confident in science lessons. It is likely that a focus on adaptive teaching will build pupil confidence by ensuring they experience success in their lessons.
  • Audit the opportunities for joy in the curriculum; it is likely that there is a virtuous cycle with enjoyment of lessons building results which leads to more joy.

What does the study suggest about the effect of behaviour, curriculum and pedagogy on performance?

  • Pupils who reported that their lessons provided instructional clarity (meaning they scored their teacher highly on questions such as “my teacher is good at explaining science” or “my teacher gives me helpful feedback on my work”) performed better.
  • There is a positive association between school performance and headteachers reporting that their school places an emphasis on academic success. This was the strongest predictor of average score of all the school characteristic measurements.
  • Schools in which pupils report disorderly or bullying behaviour show a negative association with performance in both year groups.
  • Where pupils feel a greater sense of belonging, their results are higher.
  • Pupils are less likely than the international average to conduct science experiments at least weekly.
  • Starting the GCSE course provision in Year 9 does not affect the average score on these tests.
  • Science lessons are less likely to be disrupted in Year 9 than maths lessons.

Implications for teachers and leaders

  • Consider the extent to which all pupils feel a sense of belonging in their science classroom. Do they see themselves as someone who is welcome and able to succeed? Survey your pupils to find insights into how to improve this.
  • Audit your department’s number of practicals; do pupils get the chance to undertake hands-on work as often as possible? Are there discrepancies between teachers and/or particular classes in terms of how many practicals they have the chance to do? Practical work is a wonderful opportunity to build joy and interest in the subject but it is vital that these lessons remain purposeful. This webinar from Ark Curriculum Plus provides support for planning purposeful practicals.
  • Seek support from SLT where behaviour is an issue in the department; not only does this have a significant impact on pupils’ performance but is also likely to affect staff morale.

What can we learn about teachers from this study?

  • 42% of Year 9 science teachers report being very satisfied with their job, compared to 13% who are less than satisfied. The teachers’ satisfaction rating does not show a relationship with pupils average scores (unlike in maths).
  • Year 9 pupils taught by teachers with between 5- and 10-years’ experience had a higher average score those taught by teachers with 20 years’ more experience.

Implications for teachers and leaders

  • Examine whether teachers’ level of experience affects the quality of their delivery; are there differences in subject knowledge or approach to pedagogy that could be addressed?

A final thought
The initial report (published in December) painted a picture of improvement and looked quite positive for pupils in England. It was only when the second report was published last week that the patterns emerged to suggest that a gap has opened between boys and girls. This clearly highlights the importance of using disaggregated data; the average is so often a blunt tool which reduces a complex picture to only one data point. Schools need to learn this lesson too and ensure that when data analysis is undertaken, the performance of subgroups is carefully examined.

Read the reports here.

Science Mastery Secondary is a subject excellence programme for 11-16, learn more.

Contact-Photo

Get in touch

Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.