Turning the page: Rewriting the future of Secondary English

4 June 2025

Michlyn Caffrey, Head of Subject for English Mastery Secondary, shares thoughts on the Curriculum and Assessment Review interim report.

 

As Head of English Secondary at Ark Curriculum Plus, I’ve spent the past few weeks reflecting deeply on the DfE’s Curriculum and Assessment Review: Interim Report. Alongside colleagues and sector partners, I’ve welcomed its ambitious tone, thoughtful questions, and – crucially – its recognition of the lived experience of teachers and students across the system. 

The report rightly identifies both the promise and the pressure that have characterised secondary curriculum and assessment in recent years. For those of us working in English education, this is both a validation of the concerns we’ve long held and an exciting opportunity to reimagine what success in English should look like.

In my work supporting schools to implement a mastery curriculum, I have seen how powerful a well-structured and inclusive approach to English can be. However, I have also witnessed the barriers that prevent many students from thriving. English, as it is often taught, tends to favour those who already possess certain forms of cultural capital: students who are fluent in academic language, familiar with traditional literary texts, or confident in conventional modes of expression. This creates a system where many learners, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds, feel excluded or underprepared. English can be elitist, and if we do not address this, we risk reinforcing existing inequalities. I believe that every student, regardless of their background, should have the opportunity to master English. We need to reconsider how we teach the subject; what we prioritise; how we assess learning, and whose voices we include, so that excellence becomes a shared and achievable goal for all.

 

What should the new Secondary English Curriculum prioritise?

 

  1. Liberate Key Stage 3: Prioritise depth over exam drilling

One of the most pressing concerns raised in the review is the narrowing of Key Stage 3. Too many schools feel pressured to begin GCSE preparation in Year 9, or even earlier. This not only truncates the opportunities for rich and diverse literary study but also undermines students’ development in reading, writing, and spoken language. 

One of the more worrying trends I’ve observed is the downward drift of exam-oriented writing scaffolds into Key Stage 3. When sentence stems designed to support exam performance are introduced too early, they can narrow students’ thinking and constrain creativity long before they’ve developed a secure understanding of how to shape ideas for themselves.

Key Stage 3 should be about broadening horizons, building knowledge, and developing fluency with increasingly complex texts and ideas. A rushed descent into exam content risks robbing students of the literary foundations they need to thrive. Let’s reclaim Key Stage 3 as a space for intellectual curiosity, creativity, and deep engagement with texts.

 

  1. Rethink assessment

Assessment reform is long overdue. The review opens the door to reconsidering the dominance of final, closed-book exams. It also considers the reduction of the “overall volume of assessment at Key Stage 4”. 

At GCSE, the pace is relentless. Teachers are forced to prioritise exam content and skills, leaving students to feel overwhelmed and unprepared. At Key Stage 3, the joys of reading for pleasure and creative writing are often sidelined in favour of preparing students for texts on the ‘GCSE spec’ instead.

I welcome the call for greater diversity of assessment methods, especially if this addresses why assessment at Key Stage 3 should not be the same as Key Stage 4.  If we want to undo years of ‘teaching to the test’, teachers and school leaders need further support in knowing how to confidently sample a knowledge domain without assessment itself becoming the primary focus. 

 

  1. Champion diverse literature

One of the most encouraging signals from the review is its support for a more diverse English Literature curriculum. A truly inclusive English curriculum must reflect the full spectrum of human experience. Literature should not only introduce students to the richness of the canon but also affirm their identities and broaden their world views. 

However, if our only aim is to help a few more students feel represented in the texts we teach, then we’re setting the bar too low. The real challenge is to design a curriculum that doesn’t ask students to leave parts of themselves at the door. One that embraces complexity, welcomes multiple perspectives, and encourages students to question the world as it is and imagine how it could be different. This isn’t just about inclusion; it’s building an English curriculum rooted in equity and justice.

This does not mean abandoning Shakespeare or the Romantics but expanding the curriculum to include rich and valuable knowledge from all around the world to deepen our understanding of literature of language. We’re already seeing the impact of a broader text selection in schools: higher engagement, deeper discussions, and a curriculum that fosters both empathy and academic rigour. National guidance that supports this shift would help ensure that every student sees themselves and the world they want to shape, in the stories we choose to teach. 

 

  1. Elevate language and oracy

The OCR report Striking the Balance: A review of 11-16 curriculum and assessment in England highlights that “GCSE English Language needs urgent attention”. This is a sentiment that many English teachers support. Although not signalled clearly in the Interim Report, a key problem with the Language GCSE is that it asks students to replicate the kinds of analysis they are doing in literature and therefore fails to expose students to the full variety and potential of the English language.

Students need to be exposed to modern forms of writing, multimedia and spoken language. More importantly, young people should be taught how to talk, how to listen and how to manipulate language in both writing and speech to communicate effectively in a modern world.

Schools are not always clear about how to teach the conventions of spoken language that enable students to speak competently in a range of contexts. I hope that in the full report, clear guidance is given on the importance of oracy in the curriculum. Oracy is central to the English classroom experience where we encourage students to discuss, argue, persuade and debate. I’d argue that whilst crucial in learning the discipline of English, it is important that the new curriculum establishes and defines what oracy looks like in every subject. 

 

Final Thoughts 

This is an important moment for English education. The review signals a shift towards a more thoughtful, equitable system; one that values deep learning, cultural literacy, and fairness. The Interim Report rightly acknowledges the lived experience of teachers and students, and I hope the review panel will rightly acknowledge the role of subject experts in shaping actual curriculum changes. 

I am excited by what lies ahead and committed to contributing our experience, insight, and optimism to the next phase. 

I’d love to hear from others in the English teaching community. What should Secondary English look like in a rebalanced curriculum? What do we need more of, and what could we do without? 

Let’s shape a curriculum that works. One for all students, in every classroom. 

 

Useful links:

English Mastery Secondary

Curriculum and Assessment Review: interim report

OCR Striking the balance report 

Contact-Photo

Get in touch

Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.