Science for All: Equity, Relevance and Reform in the Curriculum

30 May 2025

Jessica Wood, our Head of Subject for Secondary Science, shares her recipe for a reformed science curriculum and assessment framework that can unlock success for all. 

 

The interim report of the Curriculum and Assessment Review sets us an important challenge: to ensure that improved National Curriculum and assessments enable a shift from success for some, to success for all. And the route there? Getting the detail of the curriculum right, so that every student has the foundations they need to progress at each stage.  

 

Our MD Madeleine Anderson has argued how important it is that this is informed by the day-to-day experience of the classroom. This is part of a blog series where the educational leaders of each of the Ark Curriculum Plus mastery programmes share our contributions to this challenge, drawing on our twelve years of supporting schools in Ark and across the UK to implement a mastery curriculum. 

 

Across Ark Curriculum Plus, we have been hugely impressed with the Curriculum and Assessment Review interim report. This is just as true for science and not just because science is recognised as a foundational subject, setting students up for future success in a rapidly changing world. It is also because of the serious and practical focus on social justice – “success for all.” The disadvantage gap in science is stark, as we have seen yet again in the most recent TIMSS report.  

 

The Science Mastery team is in and out of schools every day, in Ark and across the UK, working hands-on to support them to close this gap. We are proud that our pilot programme showed a reduction in the gap between pupils receiving the Pupil Premium and those who did not, so we know what it takes to move the needle in this space. In this post, I explore what we see holding back students, from the biggest questions down to the crucial details. 

 

Equity in the Science curriculum 

The TIMSS report I referred to above clearly shows the unequal access to high-quality science education, particularly in disadvantaged areas. Our experience aligns with other sector organisations contributing to the C&A Review call for evidence, including the ASE: that this disadvantage gap is exacerbated by the two-track system created by triple science. It is not just the structure of the curriculum that undermines equity; the content of the KS4 curriculum does not support all pupils to feel included within the discipline.  

 

What could this look like? 

  • AC+ is a proponent for changing the structure of the curriculum as KS4 so that there is no “Triple Science” option.  In many schools, triple science (also known as separate sciences) is seen as the “elite” qualification for very able students. Schools often do not give more curriculum time to separate science, despite there being 50% more content than the double award. As a result, only pupils who can quickly assimilate the information required can be successful. This limits the triple science option so that pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds and those with SEND and EAL rarely are given access to this extra knowledge. As a result, they believe that they are not capable of further study of science. 
  • Ensuring that the science curriculum for everyone includes more of the most powerful content from the current Triple Science option. Our experience is that all students would benefit if content included in the combined science qualification is directly relevant to students’ lives. The 2022 report from UCL on young people’s vision for science education makes it clear that science needs to be practical and relevant to their future lives; 72% of students surveyed stated that at the moment it is not. The limited focus on environmental science and the human body does not reflect the intersection of pupils’ lives with the discipline of science. Including more content which is relevant to students’ experiences would increase the sense of belonging within the science community that traditionally many groups have been excluded from.  

 

A renewed focus on practical work 

The most recent iteration of the science curriculum removed entirely the direct assessment of practical skills at KS4 and limited this to a single yes/no judgement at KS5. The reasons for this were well founded, including the consensus that this led to teaching to the test, rather than build disciplinary skills. However, our experience aligns with the 2013 report by the Gatsby Foundation and Wellcome Trust, and many other bodies feeding into the current review, that “studying science without practical experimental work is like studying literature without reading books”. We find that students often enjoy the practical work they carry out, but that this is often limited by time constraints within the crowded curriculum as well as teacher confidence and subject knowledge. The better solution is to improve rather than remove the assessment of practical work. 

 

What could this look like? 

  • Looking towards international approaches, there are ways to assess practical skills that have been shown to have validity. For example, this could be through a viva, or practical work under exam conditions. This would have the added advantage of benefitting those students for whom writing is a barrier, by encouraging teachers to build confidence around scientific oracy. 
  • To avoid unnecessary workload, and in keeping with the interim report’s focus on evolution over revolution, AC+ would like to see the retention of the current Apparatus and Techniques criteria so that schools are not having to redesign their curriculum or order in new equipment. 
  • We would still argue that some level of teacher assessment of practical skills at GCSE should return, to ensure that all students get access to hands-on work. The current A Level system of practical endorsement is labour-intensive for teachers. However, a more streamlined approach, focussing on judging whether students have mastered a particular competency, could support departments to consider how to build disciplinary skills over time. 
  • By assessing students’ understanding of practical work in this way, the volume of high-stakes assessment needed at the end of the GCSE course could be reduced. 

 

Emphasis on Mastery 

There is a strong push to ensure pupils develop a deep understanding of core scientific concepts before progressing. This includes a focus on sequencing knowledge so that learning builds logically over time. On visits to schools, we frequently raise concerns that science teachers focus on content coverage over depth of understanding, due to the vast amount of content present in the curriculum. Teachers seem to plough on through content, rather than precisely planning for progression in their lessons. This, along with the removal of SATS in the primary phase, means that students’ knowledge is often built on shaky foundations, so that they are not able to be flexible in their knowledge. This has been very apparent to me as a GCSE Biology examiner; many students could write scripted definitions of key terms but were unable to apply their knowledge to new contexts. It is wrong to assume this is an inevitable drawback of a knowledge-rich curriculum: A true knowledge-rich curriculum builds connections between ideas, rather than teaching knowledge out of context. While we privilege key facts and ideas, these must be explained to pupils as part of the big picture of science. 

 

What could this look like? 

  • Clearer progression from KS2 to KS3. Since the removal of SATs in science, less time is devoted to science at KS2 (Tes, 2023). This means that students often join Year 7 with a very patchy experience of science and do not have the foundations needed to be successful in KS3. It seems that some primary schools are missing an understanding of what progression looks like in science. The ASE suggestion that the yearly structure at KS2 is removed and replaced with “a progression map of key substantive and disciplinary knowledge” over the whole of KS2 would support schools to prioritise subject-specific understanding within science by foregrounding next steps for deepening student knowledge and understanding. 
  • At AC+, we believe that mastery of science comes from precise building of disciplinary skills over time, but the sheer volume of substantive concept often leads to the prioritisation of content over deeper understanding. At present, as the ASE put it: “Students who are most rewarded are those who are successful in knowledge-based tasks.” We would like to see the adaptation of the national curriculum and specifications to make clear the disciplinary skills that pupils should be able to demonstrate, including the core knowledge that underpins these skills. 

 

More contemporary issues in the curriculum 

I agree with the Royal Society’s view that “in England, the science curriculum has largely focused on developing future scientists rather than fostering a citizenry equipped to engage critically and responsibly with scientific issues, including those that may directly affect their health and wellbeing.” When I speak to students about what they enjoy and value in science lessons, it is the topics which touch their lives that spark joy. Pupils are often passionate about environmental justice issues as well as recognising a need for a better understanding of their own bodies and health. I find it remarkable that these topics are at the end of the biology and chemistry specifications, so I have sometimes seen these taught in a hurry at the end of the GCSE course, rather than having considerable time devoted to understanding the key issues.  

 

What would this look like? 

  • AC+ would like to see an increased focus in the curriculum on human physiology and health. Many students do not have a deep understanding of how their own bodies work, including the functioning of the brain. It seems ridiculous to me that so little focus is given to how to live a healthy, balanced life when surely this is one of the most important focusses of scientific research. 
  • If there is a content change following the report, we would expect a big shift in chemistry to focus on environmental and materials science. There is no more important topic than global warming when the planet is facing a climate emergency. While an understanding of structure and bonding is foundational, there is much of the chemistry curriculum that is simply not applicable to pupils’ everyday life and seriously limits their feeling that chemistry is a subject that is relevant to them. 
  • At present, subjects are taught in isolation, but AC+ advocates for improved cross-curricular links so that subjects build upon each other’s knowledge, rather than contradict them. For example, how does the study of climate change in geography support that in science? 
  • With the interim report suggesting that there is already an overfilled curriculum in science, some content would need to be removed from the course. I would suggest that within each discipline, there are concepts which are not pertinent to all pupils’ future lives and would be best taught through the A Level qualification. Fleming’s left-hand rule, while conceptually interesting, has limited relevance to students’ everyday lives and could be deprioritised in favour of more applicable content. Instead, why not teach pupils more about how heat pumps work, given that these are a key strategy for the current net zero policy. 

 

What about teacher recruitment and retention? 

There is an undeniable teacher recruitment and retention problem in science. While the report does not address this directly, it does allude to “significant problems of capacity within the system.” This is not a problem that we can solve overnight, but I believe that addressing many of the issues above will contribute to reduced pressure on teachers and therefore reduce the numbers leaving the system. 

 

What could this look like? 

  • AC+ would like to see teacher training is of sufficient quality that all science ITT graduates would be considered a subject expert in all three disciplines. We know that more support for teachers who are teaching outside of specialism is necessary to ensure that the science teacher workforce is fit for the future. While traditionally teachers often only teach biology, chemistry or physics at KS4 and KS5, I believe that by supporting departments to build teachers’ subject knowledge across all subjects, departments would be able to focus more on each individual pupils’ disciplinary understanding.  
  • An increased focus on purposeful practical work will bring the joy back into science classrooms: For many teachers, this was why they got into science teaching and on my school visits it is often what students tell me they enjoy most about science lessons. By supporting schools to see practical work as part of the curriculum, I hope that changes to the curriculum as it stands will allow science teachers to value this part of the subject.  
  • Training teachers on progression in science is a key focus for our organisation. As I alluded to above, we very often see teachers focussed on “getting through the content,” teaching lesson-by-lesson, without a clear idea of where students have come from and are going to. By emphasising a mastery approach, I hope the final report leads to changes in the structure of the science curriculum which support staff to see what progression looks like in the discipline. We agree with the Royal Society, in its response to the call for evidence suggested that “reinstating subject-specific knowledge as an essential focus within initial teacher education and throughout teachers’ professional careers” should be a key focus of changes to the education sector. 

 

In conclusion, the Curriculum and Assessment Review offers a welcome opportunity to reshape science education into a more equitable, relevant and engaging experience for all students. By addressing issues such as access to practical work, curriculum overload and the need for clearer progression in science, we can better support both learners and teachers. As we await the final report, I am hopeful reforms will be grounded in evidence and designed to empower the next generation of scientifically literate citizens. 

 

References 

Curriculum and Assessment Review: interim report  

Slip in status for primary science after Sats dropped | Tes Magazine 

Secondary Resources | www.ase.org.uk 

Royal Society response to Curriculum and Assessment Review 

“Make it more relevant and practical”: Young People’s Vision for School Science in England 

 

Join our free webinar

Join Jessica Wood for our upcoming webinar ‘Equity Without Compromise: Leading Rigorous and Inclusive Science Education‘. She will explore strategic leadership approaches to reduce variability in classroom practice and share how these approaches can support novice learners in mastering complex scientific thinking and harness assessment to drive a mastery-focused curriculum.

Book your place

Contact-Photo

Get in touch

Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.