Michlyn Caffrey, Head of Subject for English Mastery Secondary, shares thoughts on the Curriculum and Assessment Review: Final Report.
The Curriculum and Assessment Review: Final Report feels like a real turning point for English education in England. For those of us who’ve spent years trying to balance ambitious curricula with assessment pressure, this review is both welcome and demanding.
The Curriculum and Assessment Review finally puts Key Stage 3 at the forefront of curriculum change; an often (still!) overlooked stage where students slog through Key Stage 4 material years too early. Instead of building curiosity and confidence, they’re pushed into exam drills before they’ve even settled into secondary school. That’s what we need to change.
Reclaiming Key Stage 3
For too long, Key Stage 3 has been squeezed by the gravitational pull of GCSE. The review’s insistence on protecting it feels like a deep breath after years of holding one in. Too often in my work with schools, I’ve seen Year 7 and 8 students already annotating unseen extracts or rehearsing paragraph structures for questions they won’t sit for another three years. The pressure to produce analytical writing, often through rigid scaffolds like PEEL, PEEZE, or PETAL, dominates lessons. That pressure drains the joy and creativity from English, as lessons become drills for written analysis. I’ve watched the excitement of studying A Midsummer Night’s Dream or The Tempest give way to timed responses and writing frames. The result? Diminished curiosity and students who see literature as a task to complete rather than something to relish.
Instead of rushing through content, we should spend time unpicking complex themes and ideas, exploring the layers of a text, and giving space for drama and discussion that bring literature to life.
Restoring balance: rigour without losing joy
Reclaiming Key Stage 3 doesn’t mean abandoning rigour. It’s not a call for looser, lighter teaching; it’s about restoring balance. A strong Key Stage 3 curriculum should still be knowledge-rich, evidence-based, and logically sequenced so that students build mastery over time. This is what the review gets right: it recognises that depth and joy can coexist. Students should read widely, study ambitious texts, and write with purpose, all underpinned by secure knowledge of language, genre, and context.
As a Curriculum Lead, this is what excites me most about the review: permission to double down on what we know works. In our Key Stage 3 curriculum, each unit is carefully sequenced so that ideas, concepts, and vocabulary accumulate, while the love of literature stays central. We get to introduce students to Shakespeare and Brontë, but also to writers who help them see themselves and their world differently. It’s rigorous, yes, but also generous. That’s the Key Stage 3 I want to defend and develop.
Broader, more diverse text choices are central to that vision. The review’s commitment to representing varied voices gives schools the freedom to think bigger about what belongs in Key Stage 3. This is the moment to bring in writers like Grace Nichols, Chinua Achebe, Jackie Kay, or Zadie Smith alongside the traditional canon—not as add-ons, but as part of a coherent literary journey. When students read beyond the familiar, they see how language carries culture and identity. It deepens their understanding of how stories shape the world and helps them recognise their own place within it. That, to me, is what a powerful Key Stage 3 curriculum does: it builds knowledge, confidence, and curiosity all at once.
Why protecting KS3 shapes the future of English education
If we get Key Stage 3 right, everything else follows. It’s the stage that shapes habits, attitudes, and the foundations of knowledge. Protecting it isn’t just about resisting early GCSE pressure—it’s about giving students the time and space to become thoughtful readers and writers. That’s the real opportunity in this review, and it’s one we can’t afford to miss.
Learn about English Mastery Secondary or access a free programme preview.
Get in touch
Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.