Reading Between the Lines: What the Curriculum Review Really Says About Geography

12 June 2025

Hannah Sassoon, our Head of Subject for Secondary Geography, shares thoughts on the Curriculum and Assessment Review interim report. 

This is part of a blog series where the educational leaders of each of the Ark Curriculum Plus mastery programmes share our contributions to this challenge, drawing on our twelve years of supporting schools in Ark and across the UK to implement a mastery curriculum.

 

Why the Interim Report Is (Mostly) Good News for Geography 

The Interim Report could be taken as a cause for celebration for geography. It reports how GCSE uptake is on the rise, suggesting that its incorporation into the EBacc subjects has served to cement the importance of geography in the minds of school leaders. The unwieldy Controlled Assessment is long gone, and everyone is now talking about the importance of climate change, sustainability and fieldwork.

 

The Geography GCSE Uptake Paradox: More Students, But Fewer at A Level 

However, I think we are missing the bigger picture. If GCSE uptake has increased, we should see a corresponding uptake in A Level. However, data from the Geographical Association reveals an overall plateau, and a 5% decline in 2023-24. Either students didn’t really feel passionate about geography in the first place, or worse, we are majorly putting them off at GCSE. I think there might be grounds to think both are true. 

First let’s look at where students are up to by the end of Year 9. Ofsted geography subject report claims that many schools have revamped their KS3 curriculum, so they are better sequenced and more ambitious. I am happy to jump on this bandwagon! If you would like to see an example of our approach do take a look at the Geography Mastery Programme Preview. However, the Interim Report reveals that well planned KS3 is only being implemented in some schools, with 56% of schools starting GCSE content early – some as early as Year 7. This squeezing of KS3 means students miss out on studying engaging themes that are frequently skipped over at GCSE, such as global governance, glaciers and oceans. They are less likely to focus on applied skills such as fieldwork and GIS. Schools select this option to ensure better GCSE data outcomes, but what they are missing is how KS3 prepares students not just for GCSE but also for A Level and beyond.

 

Primary Geography: Firmer Foundations Needed for Secondary Learning 

If we go back a bit further, we see that marginalising is also happening at KS1-2. With a lack of geography specialists at the primary phase, and previous fads of cross curricula studies, geography often gets relegated to ‘topic studies’. Students might study topics such as rivers, then Romans, and later cities. In this approach they are often unaware they are studying geography at all and arrive in Year 7 with no foundation of what it means to ‘think like a geographer’. This is not then a great starting point for a condensed KS3! So, we can see why when students presented with choosing geography for GCSE, students might end up choosing geography for the wrong reasons e.g. ‘I want to go on the Y10 fieldwork trip’, or ‘geography has shorter answers than history’.

 

How the GCSE Curriculum Shapes Teaching 

Next, we need to look at what’s happening at GCSE. We know from the Ofsted subject report that exam specification de facto becomes the curriculum and teachers move through the body of knowledge without thinking much about what’s being taught where and why. It then becomes harder to communicate to students the purpose and value of what they are learning. For example, in some GCSE specifications all the physical geography knowledge is lumped in the first few topics, followed by those relating to human geography, and this becomes how it is taught. However, as geographers we would say that the most powerful understanding comes when we consider how human and physical factors interrelate.

 

21st Century Geography: The Need for Climate Change, Sustainability and Global Governance 

Then there is the matter of what content is taught. The 2014 curriculum sidelined climate change, so it was far less prominent than in the 2008 curriculum. All teachers I’m sure would welcome a greater focus on climate change. For us in geography it’s a multi-faceted topic that links to so many other areas of interest including ecosystems, development, migration and food security to name a few. The Interim Report also mentions the importance of sustainability. This makes some appearance in KS3 and KS4 presently, but it could be threaded into every topic. For instance, in Geography Mastery, we use sustainability as a lens through which to conduct a regional study of the Middle East. 

I would add one further to this list of 21st Century topics, which is the role of global governance and perceptions of democracy. What was once seen as stable architecture for much of society, and a core part of British values, is perhaps increasingly fragile in our rapidly changing world. These themes are absolutely the domain of geography and do make a strong appearance at KS5, but students need to engage with them further at KS3 and KS4.

 

Representation Matters: How Geography Can Reflect Students’ Real Lives 

Lastly, we turn to the all-important point of what students think and feel. The Interim Report tells us the students do not always feel represented. In geography, we can fall into the trap of looking at places ‘near to us’ as the norm, brushing over real challenges in the UK, such as food poverty. These are matters that students feel passionately about. For example, students at Ark Blake wrote letters to their MP as part of a Geography Mastery lesson on tackling food poverty in the UK, which were read out in the House of Commons.  

Exam boards could also go further to support this. Most specifications at KS4 stipulate to ‘add a case study’ at various points, encouraging teachers to select one place to represent one issue. What we want is for students to deepen their understanding of a place across multiple themes. For example, Ethiopia might be looked at as a case study for development, but also for river formation and energy security. 

So, in summary, yes, I think that curriculum changes are needed. We need to do a bit better at structuring our GCSE to include more relevant 21st Century themes and perspectives. But overall, the geography national curriculum (when it’s being taught) is quite good already. Not perfect, but pretty good. A more important strategy is to tackle the time being squeezed in KS2 and KS3 by guiding teachers better as to what good progression looks like at these key stages.

 

Fixing Teacher Recruitment, Not Just Curriculum 

Finally, I’m a bit concerned that all this focus on reviewing the curriculum is distracting us from the much graver issue facing our schools in the UK today, which is teacher retention and recruitment. Having visited around 20 schools this year, what makes the difference between a geography department succeeding or struggling is whether they have a fully staffed team of specialists. Until our government and school leaders tackle this, by making state education a more desirable and competitive sector to work in, the curriculum will remain words on paper.

 

Learn more about Geography Mastery Secondary.

Contact-Photo

Get in touch

Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.