Jess Wood is Head of Subject for Science Mastery Secondary. Here she reflects on her experience with disastrous practicals and gives tips on how to avoid them.
Many people I speak to have strong memories of the practical work from their school science lessons. The practical element of science lessons is one that fills many trainees with dread because of the myriad of ways that they can go awry. In this blog, I share some of the ways that practicals can go wrong and then share my top ways to avoid this happening to you!
I especially struggled with practical work during my first year of teaching; my mentor was not a science teacher so lots of my practical lessons were a haze of CLEAPSS cards and pure guesswork to me. The technicians would joke that my room was a practical black hole where otherwise reliable equipment would stop working and even the simplest of demonstrations would go wrong; I couldn’t even get the lemon battery experiment to work! One of my most memorable practicals was doing the sheep eyeball dissection with my Year 10s. I had worked hard to prepare them for this as I thought they might be a bit squeamish but by the time it came to it, they were all really sensible and did a great job of locating all the different parts of the eye. Towards the end of the lesson, as the students were nearly finished and rather gory-looking trays of vitreous fluid and lenses, Mr S, the Head of Year 10 came in to speak to a pupil. He was a rather stern chap; at 6ft 4 with a booming voice, he was well liked but somewhat feared by the pupils. As he entered the room, one of the pupils proudly held up the eyeball to show Mr S his dissection. At this point, Mr S did a rapid 180, almost running out of the room and straight into the toilets. He later told me that the sight of the eyeballs had caused his lunch to reappear!
When I was at school, we had a new Chemistry teacher who was keen to engage our rather fiery Year 11 class. He did the classic methane bubbles practical where you bubble methane gas through soapy water to create a mass of flammable foam, which you can then set fire to in your own hands. Unfortunately, this keen teacher did this practical with a rather large mass of bubbles, right underneath the brand-new projector that had just been installed in our classroom. The resulting fireball engulfed the projector, to the teacher’s horror and the class’s delight. I don’t think he ever explained to the head of department why the projector always had a slightly yellow display after that.
I have been speaking with some of my colleagues about their experience of practicals and they have shared some horror stories, under the promise of anonymity. One teacher tells of the time she was doing a heart dissection demonstration at the front of the classroom when she knocked a scalpel off the desk. The scalpel landed, pointy end down, in her foot, where it stayed upright for much longer than you’d expect! Luckily, the scalpel was a clean one, but this didn’t stop the pupils thinking she was going to develop pig-like superpowers.
Teachers will be keen to avoid these disaster scenarios to ensure that their practicals run smoothly and meet their objectives for students’ learning.
Here are 5 top tips: –
1. Always, always write a risk assessment
Risk assessments are one of the most painful parts of planning practicals, but they are crucial. Without a risk assessment, if an accident were to happen, there is no way for you to prove that you were carrying out the practical safely. At Science Mastery, we provide a helpful template for Risk Assessments so you can ensure yours supports safe practice. It goes without saying that CLEAPSS is an invaluable source of information.
2. Practice in advance of the lesson
Ask your technician, mentor or colleague to run you through the practical before you do it. That way you can get familiar with the equipment and techniques before you get pupils to do it.
3. Use the “Slow Practical” methodology
Slow practicals are a technique where teachers demonstrate one step at a time to pupils before releasing them to do it themselves. This manages pupils’ cognitive load, which is great for ensuring pupils take what you want them to from the practical, but also makes it much easier to keep an eye on what pupils are doing and therefore manage their adherence to safety instructions. I’ve put some links to further blogs on this below.
4. Provide crystal clear instructions for pupils
Practicals can represent information-overload for pupils. Not only are they trying to remember the science behind what they are doing while mastering using new equipment, they are also navigating the social side of working in groups in a way which they might not do in many other lessons. Therefore, it is important to plan your instructions to make things really straightforward. Science Mastery resources include visual “Integrated Instructions” for pupils, designed by an experienced technician, supporting pupils to track their way through the practical.

5. Use your department’s collective experience
When I was a beginning teacher, I was nervous to ask colleagues for support with practical work, but now I realise that science teachers are only too happy to share their hard-won expertise with those new to the profession. At Science Mastery, we have a model of Co-Planning sessions where department leaders support the subject knowledge development of the whole team; practical work is a great example of something that can be included in these sessions. As a HoD, I used to love leading these sessions, particularly when staff shared their horror stories and how to avoid them.
For further tips on making practicals purposeful, watch our webinar.
Learn more about the subject excellence programme for 11-16.
Links to slow practical blogs:
Get in touch
Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.