At Ark Curriculum Plus, we have seen the huge impact mastery has had in maths classrooms since it came to prominence in England over a decade ago, and we’re proud of the part we’ve played in this.
However, the headline impact disguises a maths mastery divide, particularly at secondary. Many teachers have thrived with mastery, but we’ve also seen many more teachers struggling to make mastery work for them.
In our recent webinar Mastery Without Missteps, our Head of Subject for Secondary Maths, Rachel Smedley, shared what leaders can do to change this.
As part of our relaunch of the reimagined Mathematics Mastery for Key Stage 3 subject excellence programme, Rachel identifies challenges that can emerge when adopting a mastery approach, and shares practical strategies that Ark has adopted to ensure every teacher sees the full benefit of mastery.
This draws on over a decade at the forefront of implementing mastery in the UK, working closely with Ark schools and our UK-wide partnership.
If you missed it, you can watch the full session on YouTube. In the meantime, here’s an overview of some of the core themes.
What ‘Mastery’ means to Ark Curriculum Plus
‘Mastery’ for us doesn’t mean memorising steps, slowing down or endlessly repeating the same types of problems. It means giving students the ability to apply what they’ve learned to solve problems they’ve never seen before. As Rachel explained during the session,
“You’ve mastered something when you can apply it to a totally new problem in an unfamiliar situation. It’s absolutely not about repetition or rigid timelines. It’s about developing deep, flexible understanding.”
It is not enough to be secure in processes and techniques, and it’s not enough to be taught to think mathematically. Both are crucial, and more.
Our approach is built around five pillars:
- High expectations for all
- Practice that builds fluency and confidence
- Communication
- Conceptual understanding
- Mathematical thinking
This philosophy underpins everything we do, from our curriculum materials to our CPD and school support.
The three biggest challenges in maths mastery implementation —and how our mastery programme tackles them
Across the 23 Ark secondaries and in our work with partners nationwide, we’ve consistently seen three challenges come up:
- More support needed for non-specialist and early career teachers
- Significant variation in student starting points, especially in Year 7
- Unreliable measures of progress
We focus on three things to address these issues: supporting every teacher’s growth, classroom practice, and data that drives action.
Underpinning all of these is the mindset of both teachers and students.
Supporting every teacher’s growth
Teaching for mastery requires even deeper subject knowledge. We know not every teacher enters the classroom as a maths specialist. And even maths specialists often value support initially to identify what children are likely to struggle with.
Rob, one of our teachers who trained in PE and now teaches Year 7 maths, shared his journey during the session and praised the lesson materials he received:
“[The programme materials] helped me to build my confidence because they’re structured… I’m going on my journey with maths.”
The Ark support model, built into the Mathematics Mastery programme used across the UK, includes:
- Protected departmental planning time
- Online and in-person CPD
- Weekly classroom visits and coaching if needed
- Open-door classrooms so teachers can learn from each other
Rachel emphasised that this kind of support helps all teachers:
“Every teacher has initial nerves at having to get up and practice. But they love the structure now. Once they’ve had a practice, they just dive into it.”
The model is grounded in the concept that everyone is both a learner and a teacher. Even seasoned teachers are coached, visited and encouraged to reflect.
Classroom practice: Strong teaching with real-time feedback
The classroom practice that ensures success with high variation in starting points in year 7 is the same classroom practice that supports great teaching at every stage.
One of the most useful tools we use is diagnostic multiple-choice questions. These are carefully designed to help teachers check for understanding and to expose common misconceptions using well-crafted questions.
Rachel emphasised the importance of acting on this feedback:
“If you’re not going to adjust the ingredients, why do the taste test?”
In other words, it is only useful to check for understanding if we respond to what we learn.
We also use backward faded scaffolding. That means we start with full support, then remove pieces until students can complete the task on their own.
“Mastery isn’t about students working on different concepts. It’s about all students accessing the same concept with different support.”
This approach keeps expectations high while meeting students where they are.
Using data that drives action
Data strategy is deeply integrated with instruction and curriculum design. We use it to help teachers understand what students know, where they are stuck, and how to close the gaps.
Rachel noted:
“It’s pointless having all of the data to hand if we don’t do anything with it.”
With tools like Smartgrade and Click Click Report teachers and school leaders can:
- See which concepts students struggle with
- Understand why students chose incorrect answers
- Compare performance across classes and schools
All assessments are curriculum aligned, so the assessment data gives teachers powerful insights into attainment gaps.
Making maths exciting outside the classroom
Mastery isn’t confined to the classroom. Our approach intentionally cultivates a culture of mathematical excitement.
Rachel emphasised the importance of engagement:
“We don’t just restrict our out-of-lesson fun to high attainers…everyone can experience that joy of maths.”
That’s why we run:
- Maths clubs like Axiom Circles
- School-wide celebrations like Pi Day
- Residential maths camps for Years 7- 9
- Network-wide maths competitions
Mastery starts with mindset
All of this comes down to one big idea. Mastery depends on the mindset of the whole community.
“We don’t want just passive students in our classrooms. We want to invigorate them to want to take maths.”
And to do that, we need teachers who are supported and empowered.
That’s why we invest in professional learning, coaching, and collaborative planning. We make sure no one feels isolated. And we help every teacher deliver consistent, high-quality instruction.
Watch the full webinar
If you’re leading maths, teaching KS3, or supporting school-wide curriculum improvement, this session is packed with real-world, scalable insights.
Watch on YouTube: Mastery Without Missteps
If you’re not yet working with Ark Curriculum Plus and want to know more about our maths mastery programme, we’d love to connect.
You can email us at partnerships@arkcurriculumplus.org.uk or access sample resources.
Take a look at the full Maths Mastery Secondary programme, including what’s new for 2025.
Get in touch
Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.