In our new structure, we have a dedicated educational leader for each subject. In this series we introduce the new Head of Subject for each programme and their vision for the next five years of mastery.
Sarah is our new Head of Subject for English Primary. Below, we ask her three big questions.
Qu1: What’s the current state of English teaching at primary, and what are the biggest challenges now holding us back?
Since I first qualified as a teacher – over twenty years ago – primary education has seen many hard-won gains and meaningful improvements. The way we teach English today is markedly different from how it looked back then, and rightly so. There is much to celebrate in the continued rise in standards across primary English. And recent years have seen a steady recovery from the decline in attainment caused by COVID-19, with progress edging back towards pre-pandemic levels. However, I believe that there are three big challenges we still need to overcome:
1. The current system isn’t delivering for all pupils
In 2024, nearly 4 in 10 key stage 2 children did not meet all the standards they need to thrive in secondary schooling. Persistent gaps in attainment remain – especially for socio-economically disadvantaged pupils and those with SEND, who too often do not make the expected progress when compared to their peers.
I share the widely held ambition of promoting high standards in education. Too often, this translates to high standards for some, rather than for all. If we are serious about equity, then this is our biggest challenge to overcome as a profession: we must improve outcomes for those learners who are currently held back by structural barriers in our curriculum and assessment system. Only then can we truly offer every young person the opportunity to thrive.
2. Under-prescription in the primary English curriculum impedes mastery
Primary teachers frequently tell me that there is too much content within the English curriculum. Yet, I do not believe that the English programme of study is over-prescribed – quite the opposite! For me, the major challenge is its under-prescription, which prevents pupils obtaining an appropriate depth of understanding. The vagueness of broad statements such as ‘becoming very familiar with key stories,’ and ‘writing poetry’ lack specificity and create confusion.
I’ve seen in many schools how this under-prescription counter-intuitively contributes to greater curriculum volume: teachers repeat content in each year group with little progression, due to a lack of clarity about what has come before and what is coming next. This is why teachers often report an experience of curriculum overload. It’s not because there is too much content: it’s because the content is too ambiguous.
We know that securing mastery in English is vital for raising standards and enabling future expertise. But the current lack of specificity impedes mastery. The deficiency of precision, coupled with the absence of clearly defined pre-requisites and dependents, hinders progress and undermines standards.
3. Writing assessments do not assess pupils’ ability to write fluently
A former Y6 teacher, I understand the pressures that schools face and the need for pupils to perform well at the end of key stage 2. The writing Teacher Assessment Frameworks do not incentivise the effective teaching of writing fluency. They promote a shallow approach to learning: a ‘banking system.’ Once a pupil has ticked the box, they have ‘met’ that statement (even if they subsequently go on to forget it).
In many schools, pupils spend considerable classroom time reproducing polished pieces to meet assessment criteria, which is unrepresentative of the writing they produce across the curriculum. This reduces the time available for breadth of learning, with a knock-on impact on time for other subjects. In addition, there are concerns around the consistency of judgements across different Local Authorities, due to the inherent ambiguity of level descriptors.
Similarly, the end of key stage 2 assessment on grammar, punctuation and spelling often leads to the teaching of these features in isolation, at the expense of a sound understanding of writing. The test encourages a cram and forget approach; pupils know that they only have to remember the material for long enough to tick the right box in the paper, and they can then forget it. There is no incentive for pupils to gain the deep understanding that is needed for long-term recall.
Assessment reform is needed to better equip pupils to use the foundational building blocks of writing fluently, and to secure core concepts at a sentence level, before moving forward. This avoids gaps and errors forming and growing in the first place, which is of paramount importance – as these are difficult to remedy later on.
Qu2: What is your vision for English Mastery?
My vision for English Mastery is to improve the literacy outcomes of all pupils, with a curriculum and assessment approach that promotes fluency and facilitates mastery.
For me, pupils speaking, reading or writing accurately only under very carefully managed conditions is not mastery. You have only mastered something if you can do it automatically, and that means being able to do it under any condition. Mastery in English is being able to do something not until you can do it right, but until it is awkward to do it wrong. Mastery goes beyond recall; it requires deep understanding and the ability to apply knowledge in different contexts – to close what we refer to as the ‘knowing-doing’ gap.
Central to my vision is the belief that all pupils are capable of achieving mastery, when provided with the right support. English Mastery lessons break learning down, manage cognitive load, develop fluency and get the conditions right for mastery, but that’s not to say that pupils find learning easy – nor should it be. Struggle is a natural and necessary part of the learning process; mastery ensures pupils persist until understanding is secure.
Fluency, particularly in key stage 2, is a vital component of that vision. We prioritise fluency because it reduces cognitive load. We know that working memory can only hold a few items for a limited period of time. Given these limitations, it is understandable that pupils struggle to comprehend if they are not fluent readers and that they struggle to write confidently, and are prone to making basic errors, if they are not fluent writers.
Once something is known to automaticity, however, it occupies very little space in working memory. It becomes habitual. This frees up the brain to engage in more complex forms of thinking: automaticity is a gateway to being able to think critically. That’s why, as part of my vision for English Mastery, we ensure that all learners – and especially those with smaller working memory capacities – are given the practice time needed to acquire fluency.
Qu3: What’s your dream for English teaching in five years’ time?
My dream is for an English curriculum and assessment system that truly does deliver excellence for all children, especially those from socio-economically disadvantaged backgrounds and pupils with SEND.
In five years, I hope every primary teacher has access to a coherently sequenced English progression framework, one that offers clarity and precision about what pupils need to know, remember, and do, particularly in sentence construction. A curriculum that promotes fluency and facilitates mastery will enable all pupils to ‘keep up, not catch up’. This tackles the long tail of underachievement, addressing cumulative dysfluency, by preventing the accumulation of learning gaps over time.
At the heart of this vision is an assessment system that ensures all pupils master important foundational knowledge, and develop automaticity in key skills, from the outset. But for this to become reality, schools need the right support: support to implement a clear progression framework and to embed a mastery approach that prioritises long-term learning.
Ultimately, my dream is that all children experience English as a subject they can succeed in – one that builds their confidence, deepens their understanding, and sparks a lifelong love of literature.
Get in touch
Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.