Grammar: Theory vs Application – What Really Matters in Key Stage 2?

9 December 2025

Sarah Spink, Head of Subject for English Mastery Primary, shares thoughts on Key Stage 2 grammar curriculum, following the Curriculum and Assessment Review: Final Report.

 

If you were drafting the new Grammar Programme of Study, what would you retain, re-sequence, or remove?

 

‘I went to a school that taught grammar. In three months I learned everything – except to speak and write grammatically.’

Mark Twain

 

The grammar of the English language generates a disproportionate degree of passion, inspiring organisations such as the Apostrophe Protection Society and pedantic correctionists on quests for grammatical perfection.

And sure, grammar matters: in primary schools, accurate grammar can be the difference between a pupil being assessed as ‘working towards’ or reaching the ‘expected standard’ at the end of KS2.

The Curriculum and Assessment Review’s call to revisit grammar feels long overdue for English Leads. For years, we’ve witnessed pupils who can confidently label a subordinating conjunction yet struggle to use one. And when they do, we see adherence to ‘rules’ that often make writing mechanical and get in the way of clear, fluent communication.  It has led to the curious phenomenon of children who know about grammar but don’t use grammar effectively – a mismatch the Review captures neatly.

For leaders, recognising and addressing this gap is essential to shaping a curriculum that strengthens both knowledge and practical application.

The Review invites English Leads to reflect on how grammar is sequenced, taught and assessed across their schools. We may soon be waving a polite goodbye to some long-standing theoretical quirks (the subjunctive mood sends its regards) and welcoming a more functional, developmental approach to teaching grammar.

This blog explores what a genuinely usable KS2 grammar curriculum might look like, grounded in evidence, developmental progression, and – crucially – the realities of classroom practice. (And yes, we’ll talk about fronted adverbials.)

And then I’ll ask you the same question – especially if you’re leading English in your school: If you were drafting the new programme of study, what would you retain, re-sequence or remove?

 

‘It will be proved to thy face that thou hast men about thee that usually talk of a noun and a verb, and such abominable words as no Christian ear can endure to hear.’

Henry VI Part 2, Shakespeare

 

1. The grammar review’s central argument: use over theory

The proposal to rebalance grammar towards use rather than theory is not an attack on explicit instruction. It’s an argument for ensuring explicit instruction results in improved writing.

Too often, the assessment tail has wagged the curriculum dog: if the KS2 tests ask for identification, schools teach identification. But children need to understand how grammatical structures influence voice, cohesion, clarity, and effect – not simply how to categorise them. Grammar is far less useful when it is taught in a vacuum, detached from meaning.

If terminology enables pupils to discuss, edit, or refine their sentences, brilliant. If it simply enables them to tick the boxes, while continuing to produce sentences like “Quickly, the boy ate his toast” … then something has gone awry.

The Review proposes a reset: grammar not as a taxonomy to be memorised, but as a set of tools for shaping writing.

This is welcome. But it also raises the inevitable question: Which tools should pupils actually master?

 

‘The task of the modern educator is not to cut down jungles but to irrigate deserts.’

S. Lewis

 

2. Retain, re-sequence, or remove? (And why it matters)

Let’s imagine we really were drafting the new programme of study. The KS2 grammar requirements (pages 66 to 69 of the current National Curriculum) include a broad and sometimes ambitious range of terminology and concepts. Some deserve to stay. Some need moving. Some could politely retire.

 

‘If you have any young friends who aspire to become writers… the second greatest favour you can do them is to present them with a copy of The Elements of Style. The first greatest, of course, is to shoot them now, while they’re happy.’

Dorothy Parker

 

Retain (but reframe around purpose)

These concepts have clear links to meaning-making and writing fluency:

  • Sentence types and boundaries, including accurate demarcation
  • Subordination and coordination for controlling clause relationships – teaching contrast, cause and condition, with conjunctions as meaning-makers:

“Although the storm battered the windows, the lighthouse keeper stayed at his post.”
not
“Although it was Tuesday, I went to school.”

  • Expanded noun phrases for precision and description that actually enhance detail:

“The old oak tree, gnarled by centuries of wind, creaked softly.”
rather than
“The tall, green, big tree stood there.”

  • Cohesive devices, including pronouns, conjunctions, adverbials, taught through purpose:

“Before the sun had even risen, Maya was already halfway up the hill”
not
“Suddenly, he brushed his hair” (did he, though?)

  • Punctuation that affects meaning, including commas for clarity, apostrophes, inverted commas for dialogue
  • Vocabulary choice, including synonym/antonym work in context

These contribute meaningfully to sentence variety, control, clarity, and writerly voice.

 

‘Careful writers choose their constructions. Good writers know why they choose them.’

David Crystal

 

Re-sequence (because children grasp it later than we pretend)

Some content currently sits too early, placing cognitive demands ahead of development:

  • Perfect form (present perfect especially) – arguably KS3, introduce in context with narrative time-shifts, not as a stand-alone feature
  • Passive voice – move this later, when children can distinguish authorial choice from syntactic novelty
  • Relative clauses – teach later, once pupils can reliably control simple and compound sentence structure; otherwise, we create the phenomenon of:
    “The dog, who was brown, ran.”
  • Adverbials of place/number/manner – taught through writing, not as classification

Re-sequencing is not about lowering expectations, it’s about aligning instruction to cognitive readiness so writing actually improves rather than fragmenting under terminology overload.

 

‘Writing improves in direct ratio to the things we can keep out of it.’

William Zinsser

 

Remove (or at least de-emphasise)

These items fall into the “technically interesting but instructionally dubious” category:

  • Subjunctive form
    Unless we’re all suddenly writing Regency etiquette manuals, let it go.
  • Punctuation-for-punctuation’s-sake
    A semi-colon between two loosely connected ideas is not an act of mastery. (A child can insert a semi-colon without understanding why the ideas belonged together in the first place.)
  • Overemphasis on labelling
    Determiner taxonomy (articles vs demonstratives vs quantifiers) is rarely the hill a young writer needs to die on. If the terminology does not serve writing craft, it is not serving the pupil.
  • Fronted adverbials as a classification exercise
    (Their use can stay, but the terminology obsession doesn’t need to.)

These concepts may remain within secondary linguistics, but KS2 should prioritise transformational impact over theoretical coverage. The trade-off? Reducing theory means freeing up time for purposeful sentence-level craft. But we must resist the temptation to lower expectations; the aim is simplification, not impoverishment. Fewer items taught more purposefully will produce stronger writers than long lists taught shallowly.

 

‘Grammar is not just a pain in the ass; it’s the pole you grab to get your thoughts up on their feet and walking’

Stephen King

 

3. Developmental Progression: What Children Can Use vs Name

KS2 pupils can learn a surprising amount of grammar – but naming does not equal mastery. A core problem is the misalignment between metalinguistic understanding and sentence-construction ability.

A Year 4 child may accurately define a subordinate clause yet be unable to produce one that enhances meaning. This is why we repeatedly see tokenistic additions:

“Because it was raining, I put on my coat.”

Perfectly correct. Entirely unsurprising. Functionally identical to “I put on my coat because it was raining.”

The Review stresses that progression should reflect linguistic development, not the increasing complexity of labels. Research supports this:

  • Younger writers benefit from oral rehearsal and sentence combining before clause analysis.
  • They master function (what the sentence does) long before form (how it is constructed).
  • Secure control comes through deliberate practice, not identification.

In other words, children learn to use the tool before they learn to name it.

A reformed programme of study should sequence grammar in the order children acquire syntactic control – not in the order adults can create tidy taxonomies.

Progression should therefore emphasise control before complexity:

  • Lower KS2: secure simple, compound, and basic complex sentences; teach adverbials as tools for clarity.
  • Upper KS2: develop flexibility – subordinating for nuance, shifting clause order, manipulating cohesion devices, controlling dialogue punctuation to support narrative pace.

If children cannot yet hold a sentence in working memory long enough to manipulate clause order, teaching them to identify the subjunctive is… optimistic.

 

‘Be short. Be simple. Be human.’

Sir Ernest Gowers (The Complete Plain Words)

 

4. Towards a Balanced Approach: Explicit Instruction and Meaningful Application

Explicit instruction works. Pupils benefit from being shown models, practising structures and learning the language of grammar so they can talk about writing like writers.

But explicit instruction without meaningful application creates feature-hunting. It leads to the sticker-book approach to grammar, where children add one fronted adverbial, one expanded noun phrase and one subordinating conjunction simply to prove they can.

A revised Programme of Study must strike a balance between clarity and creativity. It should prioritise:

  • mastery of purposeful grammar
  • explicit teaching that leads to fluency
  • rich opportunities for application
  • coherence across year groups
  • fewer concepts taught with greater depth

If the Review leads us towards grammar that helps children craft sentences of impact and intention, rather than sentences that simply meet criteria, then it is a change worth leading.

 

‘I have spent most of the day putting in a comma and the rest of the day taking it out.’

Oscar Wilde

 

5. So Over to You…

If you were drafting the new KS2 Grammar Programme of Study:

  • What would you retain?
  • What would you re-sequence?
  • What would you remove?

I’d love to hear your thoughts.

 

Author: Sarah Spink, Head of Subject for Primary English

Find me on LinkedIn

 

Learn about English Mastery Primary or access a free programme preview.

Contact-Photo

Get in touch

Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.