Madeleine Anderson, Managing Director, shares thoughts from Ark Curriculum Plus on the Curriculum and Assessment Review interim report.
A few months ago, I shared some of our hopes and fears for the ongoing Curriculum and Assessment Review. Since then, the Review published its interim report.
The verdict? Top marks. I am so impressed by the serious, professional analysis it contains. It makes me optimistic for the sector. Take a look below for my top ten reasons to love the interim report.
However, the best marks available at this stage are only “so far so good”. The last two of these ten reasons are also where particular dangers lurk. I’ve included below more on these two potential pitfalls, and what we have to get right in this pivotal next stage to ensure changes to the National Curriculum pave the way to excellence. This includes an even more thoughtful approach to how changes are phased; and a prominent role for expert practitioners in shaping the fine detail of curriculum changes.
We share some of this responsibility at AC+, to feed in what we’ve learned from twelve years of putting mastery into practice in Ark schools and across the UK. We’ll be sharing a blog series over the coming weeks from our Heads of Subject, the educational leaders for each of the Ark mastery programmes, who will lay out their ideal recipes for a revitalised National Curriculum in their subject. Look out for their thoughts on what they would change, move or remove.
Reason 1: It Is Shaped by Objective Data at Every Stage.
Jonathan Simons has already pointed this out before me in the context of the EBacc, where he noted the excellent analysis in the interim report on the longer-term trends in subject take up. It is evident throughout, for example in powerful destinations data informing review of vocational qualifications, or grade progression data supporting review of post-16 level 2 study.
Reason 2: It Is Unwilling to Accept High Rates of Failure.
We’ve got so used to school-level data showing poor assessment outcomes for children with SEND or facing disadvantage, that we were in danger of no longer seeing it, or of accepting this as an inevitable fact of life. The interim report shows no complacency, no sense that this is the best we can expect. Instead, it shines a spotlight on this, bringing renewed ambition and urgency to our fight against disadvantage, and an absolute focus on what will shift the dial.
Reason 3: It Doesn’t Throw Out things Associated with the Previous Political Regime.
The interim report recognises the huge gains over the last ten years we have seen from a knowledge-rich curriculum, reflected in our international rankings; and that this is what we need to build on to address these stubbornly poor outcomes. With a new Government, it could have been tempting instead to make this an attack on what came before. This would have risked eroding the gains we’ve made, without doing anything to ensure they are shared more widely. Instead, this is the report for anyone that cares first and foremost about social justice.
Reason 4: It is Based on an Inspirational, Unifying Vision for the Purpose of Education.
The interim report returns to the elegantly crafted goal in the Call for Evidence, for a curriculum that “represents our society’s collective investment in conferring our precious knowledge and skills to the younger generation”. This beautifully cuts through false dichotomies between the enriching and the useful, or between the traditional and the modern.
Reason 5: It is Not Ideologically Blinkered.
We don’t see “knowledge-rich” used as a pretext to resist change where it is needed. Instead, the report clearly leaves room for evolution in what we as a society see as valuable to pass on, recognising that new knowledge will become relevant, and that old knowledge will cease to be relevant. I particularly liked “higher order domain-specific problem-solving ability” – a phrase we would only see in a report that has listened properly to all sides and is treading the narrow path to excellence.
Reason 6: It Doesn’t Chase Political Headlines.
Let’s take a moment in particular to be grateful that we don’t see big statements that a revitalised curriculum should primarily serve the economy, or unreconstructed ideas about 21st century skills.
Reason 7: It Doesn’t Dismiss Concerns out of hand and Always Looks for Nuanced Solutions.
We see a clear line held that we should not fundamentally change the format of assessments in ways that could undermine rigour or add to teacher workload. However, it doesn’t just use that to shut down debate. Instead, it listens thoughtfully to concerns about the “inclusivity of the assessment system for young people with higher levels of SEND” and leaves open potential accommodations for this.
Reason 8: It Doesn’t Present Curriculum and Assessment Change as a Silver Bullet.
The interim report remains realistic that excellence depends on a range of factors outside the scope of the Review, “from structures and resources to pedagogical arrangements” – and above all, excellent teaching. This is exactly why we created the Ark mastery programmes. Curriculum choices matter, but we can’t stop there. Much more is needed to support every teacher to achieve subject excellence.
Reason 9: It Makes a Positive Case for a “Practical” Approach Rather Than “Theory-Instigated” Reform.
We see explicit understanding that the greatest impact will come from incremental improvement, based on an intimate understanding of what is working in practice, rather than “an ideal curriculum at the policy level”. This is exactly our experience at AC+ – there is plenty of theory behind the Ark mastery programmes, but our best work has come from being part of a school network, held to account by practitioners and subject leaders grappling with the content every day.
Avoiding Pitfall 1: Expert Practitioners Must Have a Prominent Role.
An important challenge set out in the interim report is how we ensure that improved National Curriculum and exam specifications enable a shift from success for some to success for all. The key to this is leaving sufficient space for all students to master foundational knowledge at each stage, to achieve the depth which meaningful breadth is built on.
It’s hard to think of any challenge that the “practical” approach would be more suited to than this. The crucial question is, as the Review panel now inevitably delegates to subject experts, will the follow-through do justice to this approach? Who will hold the pen on actual curriculum changes? How much space and remit will they have to bring together practitioners at the coalface and debate each of the important details?
The answers to these questions will determine whether this interim report is just a lovely read, or paves the way to excellence.
Reason 10: It Gives Real Consideration to How Change Affects Educator Wellbeing.
The report conveys real understanding of how change affects educator wellbeing. But rather than just accepting this as a necessary evil, there is serious engagement with how to mitigate this impact through prioritisation and phasing. A phased programme of work, with incremental reforms that don’t destabilise the system; prioritising changes that lead to meaningful improvements in outcomes; based on an appraisal of risk and benefit; with consideration of capacity issues, noting the significant impact on workload. What more could we ask for?
Avoiding Pitfall 2: We Must Think Even Bigger about How Changes are Phased.
The intention is right, but the pivotal question is, will this go far enough?
I noted above how encouraging it was to see it recognised that curriculum reform is only one factor in achieving success for all. If excellent teaching is paramount, then too much curriculum change at once will not just be a workload issue, but actively harmful to standards. The next layer of curriculum planning will be rushed and inevitably lower quality; and the focus on curriculum rewrites will distract from ensuring every teacher has the support they need.
My first question is, can we stagger when change takes effect across subjects to mitigate this? We saw when schools rushed to respond to a new Ofsted framework the huge impact of curriculum writing on school workloads. The more carefully a school has mapped out the curriculum, the more work it is to maintain those gains. Primary teachers and many secondary SLT will be doing this across multiple subjects. We will support AC+ partner schools through this change, but many schools and trusts will be doing this alone. It can make a big difference if we don’t do this in every subject at once.
It is not just teachers who are affected by phasing, it is also students directly. My second question is, how “phased” can we go within each subject? For example, starting with changes at KS1 only is very different from starting in KS1 and KS4 at the same time, or starting in KS2 and KS4 at the same time.
KS1 and KS4 are a particularly tempting combination, with the least overlap in teaching teams working on both. But with Ark mastery programmes at KS3 in maths, science, English and geography, we can say with some certainty that schools pay great attention to how KS3 prepares children for KS4, even while prioritising a rich three-year KS3 experience. The children in the first cohort on a new exam spec will already be at a disadvantage. What is the further impact if they are moving straight to a new KS4 exam spec that was not anticipated during their KS3 years? And will schools really postpone changes to KS3, or will there be a moral obligation to change KS3 sooner to align with the new KS4 – with the risk that KS3 changes twice when a new National Curriculum follows?
KS1 and KS3 might also look tempting as a combination. But can we set KS3 up for long term success, if they are still seeing such variation in what knowledge children are leaving primary with?
Other jurisdictions roll out curriculum change a year group at a time. We are all impatient to get closer to excellence faster than that. But the more we can roll this out from earlier year groups to older year groups, the better.
In Summary
How refreshing to read something that doesn’t fall into one side or another of a toxic debate, that rises above tribalism and engages objectively with what each side of these debates has to offer. This is the attitude we need to move forward as a sector. It is no coincidence that this has come from the leader of the EEF, an organisation that has already done so much to support and elevate teaching as a profession.
I have total faith that this utter professionalism will endure in the final recommendations. If we can go further and get the crucial fine details right, and the recommendations survive all the political realities, the next decade will be an exciting one.
In summary, a promising start!
Get in touch
Let us know you’re interested by completing this form. Our team will be in touch to arrange an informal meeting to discuss your school’s needs.